Skip to Content

Benjamin Moore vs. Behr, Which Is the Better Paint?

Benjamin Moore and Behr are both quality paints definitely worth your money, but when compared, which of these two is the better choice? It really depends on your personal preferences. However, before you can make an honest choice, you’ll want to fully understand the pros and cons of Benjamin Moore and Behr.

Benjamin Moore Paint

Benjamin Moore is sold at a wide variety of paint and home improvement stores and offers their customers three common kinds of paint, semi-gloss, flat, and eggshell. These paints are designed for both residential and commercial projects. They’re durable, splatter resistant, easy to spread, and are fast drying.

All of Benjamin Moore’s paints are cost-effective except their Regal paint which is a higher quality product. This luxury paint runs around $50 a can, but it’s definitely worth the money. It can cover a wall or ceiling a wall in 2 coats or less and looks amazing once the paint has fully dried.

Benjamin Moore Aura Paint

Even better than Regal is Benjamin Moore’s Aura. This paint has the best hide out of all their products and is the most durable too. Aura is very comparable to Behr Marquee. If you have children, you can feel confident knowing that Aura paint can be washed multiple times to remove grime, dirt, and stains. It’s durable, offers great coverage, and the paint will never fade or rub off no matter how many times you wash it.

Behr Paint

Behr is only sold at Home Depot stores throughout the country and offers their customers a very limited selection. In fact, Behr only has 3 premier products. They include Behr Premium, Plus Ultra, and Behr Marquee. Marquee is Behr’s luxury paint and like mentioned above, it’s very comparable to Benjamin Moore’s Aura paint.

Behr Marquee Paint

Marquee is durable, easy to spread, has great coverage, and has an amazing hide. The only drawback to Marquee paint is the limited selection. You’ll have to pick from the Behr Marquee Collection.

Those individuals who are interested in a specific color that’s not included in the Behr Marquee Collection should use Behr Premium Plus Ultra. You’ll have a much wider selection of colors to choose from, and you can even create your own color combinations.

The only downside is that you’ll have to apply more than one coat to successfully cover a particular surface. That’s the only difference between Marquee and Premium Plus Ultra, the amount of coats it takes to cover a given surface. The best part? Behr Premium Plus Ultra paint has primer mixed in for your convenience.

Behr Paint vs. Benjamin Moore Paint

Benjamin Moore is sold through owner-operated stores. The upside is these stores can offer significantly more informed advice than you can get at Home Depot. (The BM selection brochures are outstanding.) The downside is these stores have less room to offer price deals. On an equal grade basis, Benjamin Moore paint is higher density, with better application properties – marginally so, however.

On a big project, the higher cost is a bit painful. I use Behr for utility applications, and BM for showcase rooms. And Benjamin Moore for any exterior, severe traffic or deck applications. If I have to go up on a ladder or refinish a deck, the extra cost is worth it.

Consumer Reports, a media outlet that evaluates different products, compared Benjamin Moore and Behr paint to see what the better product was. According to their evaluation, Benjamin Moore beat Behr by just a little as the top-performing interior paint, and they did this by beating Behr in 2 out of the 3 categories. However, Behr beat Benjamin Moore when it came to the category of value.

Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC’s)

Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC’s) are toxins that are commonly found in a variety of paints. These compounds can cause health problems like respiratory issues and can contribute to air pollution. In California for example, paints sold in stores and online are not allowed to have more than 50 grams of VOCs per liter.

Nearly all of your top-rated paints have little or zero VOCs. In fact, it’s becoming the norm. Most companies have at least tried to decrease the amount of VOCs in their paint.

Now, when it comes to Benjamin Moore, the tint used in this paint have absolutely no VOCs at all. Behr paints on the other hand have low-VOC colorants.

Another thing that you’ll want to remember is the higher the VOC percentage, the harder it is to spread the paint, but it does not make much difference when compared to the low-VOC paints. In addition to this, paints with higher levels of VOCs also require more coats. This is why choosing a higher quality paint like Benjamin Moore or Behr is so important.

Choosing between Benjamin Moore and Behr

Benjamin Moore paints and Behr paints are very comparable in just about every single way. However, there are a few differences. Behr paints tend to be a little more affordable than Benjamin Moore paints, yet Benjamin Moore received a higher rating from Consumer Reports. In addition to this, Behr tends to have more color options when compared to Benjamin Moore.

When trying to choose between the two brands, first decide what color you want and the amount of money you have available. After that, it really boils down to personal preference.

Mike Bailey

Thomas

Tuesday 30th of November 2021

I think you must be reading an old Consumer Reports because the current reviews show the Behr Marquee with a score of 88 and the Benjamin Moore Aura with 83 and the price difference is quite a bit more for Benjamin Moore [$46 vs. $84]

Cherie Hufton

Sunday 19th of September 2021

What Benjamin Moore paint do I use to paint newly installed gib in a bathroom and kitchen. Does Benjamin Moore paint have the primer or sealer in the paint or do I need a primer /sealer coat and then a couple of top coats?

Cherie Hufton

Sunday 19th of September 2021

1. What paint (in the Benjamin Moore range) do I use on new gib and gib stopped walls and ceiling’s in a bathroom and kitchen? 2. Can I get a colour match to a Dulux colour?

Chris Rutledge

Saturday 13th of June 2020

BM is sold though owner operated stores. The upside is these stores can offer significantly more informed advice than you can get at Home Depot. (The BM selection brochures are outstanding.) The downside is these stores less room to offer price deals. On an equal grade basis, the BM paint is higher density, with better application properties - marginally so, however. On a big project, the higher cost is a bit painful. I use Bher for utility applications, and BM for showcase rooms. And BM for any exterior, severe traffic or deck applications. If I have to go up on a ladder, or refinish a deck, the extra cost is worth it. As an aside, Sherwin Williams is a great brand, and seem to offer significant sale deals freqently.

i_taz

Friday 3rd of April 2020

VOC's makes it's harder to spread...??? These new paint's like SW Essence is like a gel and doesn't spread at all plus the brush marks are extreme. Flotrol and lots of it, like 15-20%, is mandatory in these new low VOC paints.